When dealing with international trade and shipping, understanding Incoterms (International Commercial Terms) is crucial for businesses and individuals alike. Two of the most common Incoterms are FOB (Free on Board)Â and EXW (Ex Works). These terms define the responsibilities, costs, and risks involved in the shipping process for both buyers and sellers. In this article, we will compare FOB vs EXW, exploring what each term means, how they differ, and how to choose the best one for your needs.
What Are Incoterms?
Incoterms are a series of standardized trade terms published by the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) that clearly outline the responsibilities of buyers and sellers in international transactions. They define who is responsible for the various costs, risks, and logistics involved in the shipping process, from the seller’s location to the buyer’s destination.
What is FOB (Free on Board)?
FOB (Free on Board) is a shipping term that indicates the point at which the seller's responsibility for goods ends and the buyer’s responsibility begins. The term is typically used for ocean freight shipments, although it can also apply to air cargo in some cases.
Under FOB, the seller is responsible for all costs and risks up until the goods are loaded onto the vessel at the designated port of shipment. Once the goods are on board, the risk of loss or damage shifts to the buyer. The buyer is then responsible for the cost of shipping, insurance, and any other costs incurred after the goods have been loaded onto the ship.
FOB Key Points:
Seller’s Responsibility: The seller is responsible for the costs and risks up to the point the goods are loaded onto the vessel.
Buyer’s Responsibility: The buyer assumes responsibility once the goods are on board the ship, including shipping costs, insurance, and handling after departure.
Main Cost Factors:Â The seller covers export duties, transportation to the port, and loading costs; the buyer covers the international freight and insurance.
Example of FOB:
Scenario:Â A company in the United States orders electronics from a manufacturer in China under an FOB agreement.
Seller’s Responsibility: The Chinese manufacturer covers the cost of transporting the electronics to the port of Shanghai and loading them onto the ship.
Buyer’s Responsibility: The US company is responsible for the freight cost, ocean shipping, unloading at the destination port, and customs duties.
What is EXW (Ex Works)?
EXW (Ex Works) is an Incoterm that places the least responsibility on the seller. Under EXW, the seller’s responsibility ends as soon as the goods are made available for pickup at their premises (or another agreed-upon location such as a warehouse or factory). The buyer assumes almost all responsibility for transportation, insurance, and risk from that point onward.
The buyer is responsible for arranging and paying for the transport from the seller’s premises, including export customs clearance, shipping, and import duties.
EXW Key Points:
Seller’s Responsibility: The seller simply makes the goods available at their premises or another agreed location. The seller does not arrange for shipping, export clearance, or insurance.
Buyer’s Responsibility: The buyer assumes responsibility for all transportation, including export duties, shipping, and delivery to the final destination.
Main Cost Factors: The buyer covers all costs associated with transporting the goods from the seller’s location, including customs fees, handling, and delivery.
Example of EXW:
Scenario:Â A business in the UK orders machinery from a supplier in Germany under EXW terms.
Seller’s Responsibility: The German supplier simply makes the machinery available for pickup at their warehouse.
Buyer’s Responsibility: The UK business is responsible for organizing the transport, dealing with customs clearance, and paying for shipping from Germany to the UK.
Key Differences Between FOB and EXW
Understanding the differences between FOB and EXW is essential for selecting the appropriate Incoterm based on your specific needs and logistics capabilities.
1. Seller’s Responsibilities
FOB:Â The seller is responsible for the goods until they are loaded onto the ship at the port of departure. This includes the cost of transporting the goods to the port and loading them onto the vessel.
EXW: The seller’s responsibility ends as soon as the goods are made available at their premises (or another agreed-upon location). The seller does not handle shipping or export procedures.
2. Buyer’s Responsibilities
FOB:Â The buyer takes responsibility for the goods as soon as they are loaded onto the vessel. This includes paying for shipping, insurance, and handling once the goods are in transit.
EXW:Â The buyer is responsible for nearly every aspect of the shipping process, including arranging transportation, export clearance, insurance, and paying all shipping costs.
3. Risk Transfer
FOB:Â The risk of loss or damage to the goods is transferred to the buyer once the goods are loaded onto the ship.
EXW:Â The buyer assumes all risks as soon as the goods are made available for pickup at the seller's location.
4. Control Over Logistics
FOB:Â The buyer has more control over the shipping process after the goods are loaded onto the vessel. The seller is responsible for ensuring the goods reach the port, but the buyer arranges the sea freight and insurance.
EXW:Â The buyer has complete control over the logistics, from transportation to customs clearance and delivery.
5. Cost Implications
FOB:Â The seller covers most of the costs up until the goods are loaded onto the vessel, while the buyer bears the cost of shipping, unloading, and import duties.
EXW:Â The buyer incurs all costs from the moment the goods are made available, including transport, export duties, and shipping costs.
When to Use FOB vs EXW
The decision between FOBÂ and EXWÂ depends on several factors, including the level of control you want over the shipping process and your experience in handling international logistics.
Choose FOBÂ when the buyer is more experienced in handling international shipping and wants to have control over the sea freight and shipping insurance. FOB is also beneficial when the seller has reliable port arrangements and can efficiently load goods onto the ship.
Choose EXW if the buyer prefers to have full control over the logistics from the seller’s warehouse onward and is capable of handling export customs, freight forwarding, and delivery. EXW is commonly used in cases where the buyer has an established supply chain and shipping infrastructure.
Understanding the difference between FOB and EXW is essential for businesses engaged in international trade. Both Incoterms define the division of responsibilities between the buyer and the seller, but the key distinction lies in the point at which the risk and responsibility are transferred. FOB gives more responsibility to the seller for the shipping process up until the goods are loaded onto the vessel, while EXW places the onus on the buyer to manage almost every aspect of the shipping process from the seller’s premises onward.
By knowing these differences, businesses can make more informed decisions about their international shipping terms, ensuring smoother transactions and reducing the likelihood of misunderstandings and costly errors.
FAQs About FOB vs EXW
1. Which Incoterm is more commonly used in international trade?
FOB is one of the most commonly used Incoterms, especially for ocean freight. EXW is often preferred for smaller shipments or when the buyer has full control over their logistics.
2. Is FOB used only for ocean freight?
While FOB is traditionally used for ocean freight, it can also be applied to other forms of transport, including air and land freight, though this is less common.
3. Can the buyer negotiate FOB or EXW terms?
Yes, both terms are negotiable and should be agreed upon during the contract negotiation phase between the buyer and seller.
4. Can EXW be used for shipments to another country?
Yes, EXW can be used for international shipments. The buyer is responsible for arranging all logistics, including export clearance and shipping.
Need a China-based Shipping Agent to help you consolidate and ship internationally from China?
